Skip to Content
Top

Partner Amanda Lewis Authored Amicus Brief in Support of Successful Appeal to Get Sunday Ticket Verdict Against NFL Reinstated

Sports Fans Coalition News Image

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit has reinstated a jury’s finding that the National Football League violated federal antitrust law in how it exclusively distributed games through DirecTV’s “Sunday Ticket” package. Cuneo Gilbert Flannery & LaDuca Partner Amanda G. Lewis authored the amicus brief Sports Fans Coalition filed in January 2025 urging the appellate court to reach this outcome to protect fans from inflated prices.

In June 2024, a federal jury awarded roughly $4.7 billion to residential and commercial Sunday Ticket subscribers after finding the NFL violated antitrust law. Judge Philip Gutierrez later threw out the verdict, ruling that the plaintiffs’ economic experts’ testimony was unreliable as a matter of law.

The brief Amanda G. Lewis authored on behalf of Sports Fans Coalition made three main points:

  • The NFL’s antitrust exemption is narrow. The Sports Broadcasting Act of 1961 covers only free, over-the-air broadcasts. It does not reach a pay package like Sunday Ticket sold exclusively through satellite.
  • The NFL has a history of restricting fan access. The brief pointed to the league’s defense of the sports blackout rule, which Sports Fans Coalition helped persuade the FCC to repeal in 2014.
  • The trial judge got the facts wrong. The brief challenged the court’s conclusions that no streaming alternative was feasible in 2011 and that CBS would not share its game feeds with competitors, arguing that streaming of live sports was already mainstream by 2011 and that CBS had in fact shared its feeds.

On October 30, 2026, a Ninth Circuit panel partially reversed the trial judge’s decision. It held that the district court abused its discretion by excluding the subscribers’ expert testimony as a matter of law instead of allowing the jury to assess its reliability, and it ordered the liability verdict reinstated. Damages will be decided in a new trial.

“When the trial judge tossed this verdict, it was like a ref throwing a flag on the game-winning touchdown when nobody else saw a foul. The ruling on the field was correctly overturned by the Ninth Circuit,” said Brian Hess, Executive Director of Sports Fans Coalition. “A jury sat through a month of evidence and decided the NFL broke the law. Fans who paid for Sunday Ticket got overcharged, and the NFL is now back on the hook for it–as they should be. That verdict should never have been taken away from them in the first place.”

Read Sports Fans Coalition’s full statement here: https://www.sportsfans.org/latest-news/sfc-applauds-ninth-circuit-decision-reinstating-sunday-ticket-jury-verdict-against-the-nfl

Categories: 
Litigation. Legislation. Results.

Champions in Court and in the Capital

Get In Touch With Us

Have questions? Ready to get started? Call or contact us using the form below.

  • Please enter your first name.
  • Please enter your last name.
  • Please enter your phone number.
    This isn't a valid phone number.
  • Please enter your email address.
    This isn't a valid email address.
  • Please make a selection.
  • Please enter a message.
  • By submitting, you agree to receive text messages from Cuneo Gilbert Flannery & LaDuca, LLP at the number provided, including those related to your inquiry, follow-ups, and review requests, via automated technology. Consent is not a condition of purchase. Msg & data rates may apply. Msg frequency may vary. Reply STOP to cancel or HELP for assistance. Acceptable Use Policy